Light Mix vs All Mix: Which Potting Soil Should You Use Indoors?
Share
Light mix or all mix? Use a light mix for seedlings, cuttings and young plants, and an all mix for established plants that are hungry for food. A light mix is a lightly fertilised, airy potting soil that will not scorch delicate new roots, so you can control feeding yourself from early on. An all mix is a richer, heavily pre-fertilised soil that carries enough food to keep vigorous plants growing for a while without extra feed.
This guide explains the real difference between light mix and all mix soil, shows the numbers printed on the bags we stock, and helps you decide which to buy for tomatoes, chillies, herbs, leafy greens and houseplants grown indoors.
In this article
- What is the difference between light mix and all mix?
- How do the bags compare side by side?
- When should you choose a light mix?
- When is an all mix the better choice?
- Should you add perlite to either mix?
- How do you avoid the common potting soil mistakes?
- FAQ
What is the difference between light mix and all mix?
Both are peat-based potting soils made for growing in containers, and both usually contain perlite for drainage and lime to buffer the pH. The difference is how much fertiliser is already in the bag.
- Light mix is lightly fertilised. It gives plants a gentle start and then relies on you to add liquid feed as they grow. Low starting nutrient levels make it kind to seeds, fresh cuttings and anything with a small root system.
- All mix is heavily pre-fertilised. It is designed to behave like a rich outdoor soil, so established plants can grow on for a period without any extra feed at all.
A handy way to see the difference is the EC (electrical conductivity) figure some brands print on the bag. EC is a measure of dissolved salts, which in a potting soil mostly means fertiliser. A higher number means a richer soil. On the Dutchpro range we sell, the Light Mix is listed at EC 1.3 and the All Mix at EC 1.7, with the All Mix also containing worm humus and an organic fertiliser on top of the base feed.
White and black peat with perlite and lime. pH 5.5 to 6.5, EC 1.3, so it is gentle on new roots and leaves the feeding in your hands.
How do the bags compare side by side?
Here is how the light mix and all mix soils we currently have in stock compare, using the details printed by each manufacturer.
| Soil | Type | Key details | Best for | Price (50L) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Dutch Pro Light Mix | Light mix | pH 5.5 to 6.5, EC 1.3, peat, perlite, lime | Seeds, cuttings, young plants, growers who like to control feeding | £11.00 |
| Dutchpro All Mix | All mix | pH 6.0, EC 1.7, adds worm humus and organic fertiliser | Established, fast-growing plants potted on into larger containers | £16.95 |
| BioBizz All Mix | All mix | Heavily pre-fertilised, living soil with active microorganisms | Organic growers who want minimal bottled feed early on | £16.95 |
When should you choose a light mix?
A light mix is the safer, more flexible option in most indoor setups. Choose it when:
- You are starting seeds or rooting cuttings. Tiny roots are easily damaged by rich soil, and seedlings simply do not need much food in their first weeks.
- You want full control over feeding. Because the starting nutrient level is low, the liquid feed you add is what drives growth, which makes it easier to read your plants and adjust.
- You grow slow or light feeders. Many herbs, leafy greens and houseplants are happier in a gentler soil.
The trade-off is that you will need to start feeding sooner. As a general rule for any container, the RHS advises that you should feed plants in containers about six weeks after planting, as the nutrients start to run out. With a light mix, watch for paler new growth as the sign that food is running low, and begin a gentle liquid feed then.
When is an all mix the better choice?
An all mix earns its place once plants are established and growing hard. Choose it when:
- You are potting on vigorous plants such as tomatoes, chillies, peppers or courgettes into their final containers.
- You prefer a simpler routine. BioBizz says its All Mix carries enough nutrient power to sustain lush growth for a couple of weeks without any extra fertiliser.
- You like organic growing. All mixes with worm humus or living microbes suit growers who want to rely more on the soil and less on bottles.
The catch is that rich soil can be too strong for very young plants. If you want to use an all mix for seedlings, start them in a light mix or propagation cubes first, then pot them into the all mix once they have a few sets of true leaves and a healthy root ball. BioBizz also recommends moistening All Mix and leaving it to stand for 36 hours before planting, so the fertiliser and microorganisms have time to get going.
A heavily pre-fertilised, living soil that emulates rich outdoor earth, so hungry plants can grow on without extra feed at first.
Should you add perlite to either mix?
Most light mix and all mix bags already contain perlite, so you do not have to add more. Extra perlite is still worth considering if you tend to overwater, grow in plastic pots that dry out slowly, or keep plants in a cool room in winter where soil stays wet for longer. Mixing in some extra perlite opens up the soil and helps excess water drain away.
If you want the full detail on ratios and how perlite compares with vermiculite, read our guide: What is perlite? The grower's guide to aeration and drainage.
pH neutral volcanic rock that breaks up heavy soil and lets air and water reach the roots. Ideal for lightening either mix.
How do you avoid the common potting soil mistakes?
- Do not feed on top of a fresh all mix straight away. The soil already contains plenty of food. Adding a full-strength liquid feed in the first couple of weeks is the quickest route to burnt leaf tips.
- Do not leave light mix plants unfed for too long. Pale, slow new growth usually means the soil has run out of food and it is time to start feeding.
- Match the pot size to the plant. A small plant in a huge pot of rich soil stays wet and cold for too long. Our guide on what size pot your plant needs covers this in detail.
- Water to runoff, then let it dry back. Peat-based soils hold plenty of water, so wait until the top few centimetres feel dry and the pot feels lighter before watering again.
Frequently asked questions
Can I use all mix for seedlings?
It is not recommended. All mix is heavily pre-fertilised and can be too strong for tiny roots. Start seeds in a light mix or propagation cubes, then pot them into all mix once they are established.
Do I need to add nutrients to light mix?
Yes, eventually. Light mix only carries a small amount of fertiliser, so once your plants show signs of hunger, usually paler new growth, start a gentle liquid feed and build it up as the plants grow.
Is light mix the same as seed compost?
They are similar in purpose, as both are gentle for young plants, but light mix is designed to carry plants beyond the seedling stage and into larger pots. You can use light mix from seed right through to final pot, adding feed as the plants need it.
Can I mix light mix and all mix together?
Yes. Blending the two gives you a medium-strength soil. Some growers put light mix in the top layer for young roots and all mix lower down for the roots to grow into later.
How long does pre-fertilised soil last before I need to feed?
It depends on the soil and how fast your plants grow. BioBizz says its All Mix sustains growth for a couple of weeks without extra feed, while the RHS suggests container plants generally need feeding about six weeks after planting. Let your plants guide you and start feeding at the first sign of paler growth.
Ready to fill your pots?
Browse our full range of light mix and all mix potting soils from trusted brands, all in one place.
Shop soil and light mix →Pick the right soil for every stage, from first seedlings to final pots.